In recent decades, there has been a significant shift in the religious landscape of Western societies. More and more people are disaffiliating from their religious backgrounds, leading to a larger “nones” population. For Christians this is a source of concern, as fewer people affiliate with Christian religion, and church attendance has stagnated or even decreased in many Western countries. However, examining the trend of religious disaffiliation offers an opportunity to better understand what has gone wrong and how we can respond to restore a vital spiritual life among our society. In order to address this issue, we need to explore three main reasons for the rise in religious disaffiliation, along with appropriate responses from the Church.

I. Shift Towards a Postmodern Worldview

The challenge: Individual truth claims

One of the most significant changes that impacted the religious landscape is the adoption of postmodern philosophies among the general public. In a premodern worldview, religious authorities provided the ultimate truth. However, in a postmodern age, truth is no longer found in absolute propositions, but rather is perceived as subjective. Relative truths hold as much validity as absolute ones, giving rise to a ‘truth-pluralism’. As a result, people question dogmas and religious claims, often leading to rejection of religion altogether.

The response: Embrace a dialogue

The Church’s response must be to foster an environment where dialogue and reasoned discussion can flourish. Believers should have a firm understanding of the Biblical faith but also the intellectual capacity to discuss it sensibly with an open mind towards other perspectives. This doesn't entail watering down Scriptural faith nor giving up conviction about the exclusive Truth in Christ. Rather, it means cultivating the art of hospitality, grounded in love, respect for others, and the willingness to share and explain the gospel message in ways that make sense to the enquirers, even when their questions challenge received orthodoxies or unsettling personal beliefs.

II. The Effect of Historical Scandals and Clerical Misconduct

The challenge: Damaged credibility

For those who remained faithful despite the postmodern turn, a second factor in religious disaffiliation has been a series of scandals and cases of abuse perpetrated by clerics, resulting in deep mistrust toward the institutional Church. Those who had built their faith around the Church as an instrument of God's grace suffered a profound crisis of trust.

The response: Leadership transparency & Accountability

The Church must counter this crisis by leading the way in fostering transparency and accountability. Vulnerability must come from the top down. Popes, Cardinals, Bishops, Priests and leaders must not only denounce past abuses but commit to ensuring all levels of the Church actively work towards transparency and accountability. It is essential to create new systems and structures that assure victims they will be heard, respected, and that justice will be pursued. Such actions will help restore the integrity of the Church.

III. The Impact of Progressive Secularization

The challenge: Secular worldview triumph

Another main driver of religious disaffiliation is the growing success of a secular worldview, which has permeated every aspect of contemporary Western culture. The autonomy of the individual is increasingly exalted. Religious expression, particularly expressions of transcendent belief or devotion, may be perceived as restricting to this ind of individualist thinking. Hence, the secular ethos becomes the ‘religion’ of our time, often displacing overt religious practice and commitment.

The response: Engage a holistic approach to culture

Churches must face this challenge with a holistic approach that engages individuals in matters of personal and collective well-being. A narrow focus on doctrines and practices is no longer able to compete with a broader cultural appeal. The Church needs to forge authentic relationships with the wider community, proclaim the Christian message in fresh ways, and propose alternatives to secular solutions by promoting a lifestyle of wholeness, love, and compassion. To do this, the Church must remain adaptable, yet true to its roots, ministering to contemporary needs while maintaining the message of the Gospel.

In conclusion, understanding the reasons for religious disaffiliation allows the Church to better respond to this situation. Fostering dialogue, restoring credibility through transparency and accountability, and engaging a holistic approach to culture are effective ways to counter the trend of losing one’s religion and potentially reinvigorate faith and spirituality within Western societies.


  1. Martin, S. (2017). Faith in Flux: 5 Responses to Religious Change. Nashville: Abingdon Press.
  2. Nienasz, J. (2012). The Rise of the "Nones": Understanding Secularity in America. Charlottesville, VA: Abington Press.
  3. Stark, R. (2006). For the Glory of the Nation: Faith and Politics in the Modern Era. Berkeley: University of California Press.
  4. Woodberry, R. (2012). The Missionary Roots of Liberal Democracy. Boston: Belknap Press.
  5. Zaleski, D. (2013). Restless Gods: The Making of Modern American Religion. New York: Ecco.